Cat S60 Vs Sonim XP7

Cat S60

If you want to talk about heavyweights in the smartphone world, these two will be near the top of the list.

Many smartphones now have some protection built in, mainly from water ingress and from damage to the display. Few, though, go as far as the Cat S60 and the Sonim XP7. Both are built to withstand the rigors of tough environments much better than, for example, an iPhone of Samsung Galaxy S. But, if you had to pick one, which manages to deliver the knockout punch?

Cat S60

Sonim Xp7

Size (in)

5.82 x 2.89 x 0.50

5.39 x 2.84 x 0.82

Weight

7.9oz10.2oz

Rugged Rating

IP68

IP68

Display Res

720px x 1280px

480px x 800px

Rear Camera

13MP

5MP

Front Camera

5MP1MP

Battery

3800mAh

4800mAh

Talk Time

30hrs40hrs

4G

Yes

Yes

Wi-Fi

802.11 n

802.11 n

Design

Most modern high-end smartphones weigh in at about 5.6oz, so when you see the weights of both of these, it might be a surprise. The Cat S60 is the lightweight of the two, at 7.9oz. The Sonim XP7 is actually 10.2oz. That, frankly, is heavy. Too heavy, actually, if you look what you get for your money. It’s tough, certainly, but as tough as the much lighter Cat? We’re not sure.

Despite the weight difference, the Cat S60 is actually the larger of the two. Neither, though, are too big or small to be an issue, and both sit nicely in the hand.

Sonim XP7

Sonim XP7

Both carry an IP68 rating. This makes them dust and water resistant. They will survive being immersed in up to 6 feet of water for 30 minutes. The Cat S60 is also resistant to heavy vibration, which might be crucial in some work environments. The Sonim XP7, for its part, is shock resistant, but Sonim don’t actually state to what extent.

Both run Android but, it must be said, the Cat S60 is a little newer than the XP7, and so might be a version ahead where the operating system is concerned.

Display

We should say that these aren’t designed to be multimedia devices. They’re not for sitting on a bus and watching box sets, they are working phones. This is reflected in the display specs. Both are respectable, without ever being great. The Cat is a 720 HD and the XP7 is 480px x 800px. We say again, though, if you’re buying either of these phones because of the display, you’re buying the wrong phones.

Both are okay for their purpose, though, and won’t disappoint. Size wise, the Cat is 4.7″ and the XP7 is 4″.

Cat S60 Front

Cat S60

Camera

If you’re already leaning towards the Cat, then this won’t change your mind. Both have rear and front cameras, which is a bonus, but that’s about where the good news stops for the Sonim.

The Cat S60 has a 13MP rear camera offering Full HD video recording, and a front 5MP camera. Video calling is also available. The Sonim XP7 has an 8MP rear camera, also offering Full HD video recording, but has a very disappointing 1MP front camera. If it were 3MP, or even 2.1MP, we could just shrug and move on. 1MP, though, was hardly worth the effort of including it.

CPU and Power

Both devices have a quad core Qualcomm processor, but the S60 is a generation or two up from the XP7. Despite this, the XP7 is still plenty speedy enough for any type of use. The S60 has 32GB of storage, with a Micro SD card slot for another 128GB if required. The XP7 offers 16GB, but there’s no card slot. In our eyes, that’s a pretty poor emission in this day and age.

Cat S60 Back top and bottom

Cat S60

 

The XP7 does have a much larger battery, and this probably accounts for the extra weight. At 4800mAh, it is a significant amount of power, good for 40hrs talktime, if you need it. The Cat S60 gives 3800mAh, with 30hrs of talk time. Although less than the Sonim, it’s still a massive amount of time from a single charge.

Sonim XP7

Sonim XP7

Connectivity

Both are 4G ready, with wi-fi up to 802.11 n speeds. Both also have GPS and NFC capabilities.

Conclusion

The Sonim XP7, in any other comparison, would win hands down. Unfortunately, here it’s up against the best in its class. Take the slightly disappointing ¬†display out of the equation, and the XP7 is enough for anybody. But, up against the S60, it does start to look a little weak.

Given that the difference in price isn’t particularly substantial, we’d have to say go for the S60 every time.

Rachel C.
Rachel C.
Rachel is the researcher and blog writer for the Mr Aberthon website. She grew up in Brooklyn, New York and eventually made her way to Connecticut in order to become a part of the Mr Aberthon Team. She is passionate about technology and electronics, and nothing gives her more pleasure than discovering insights into the latest gadgets to hit the electronics market.